Stripe vs Shopify Payments vs Airwallex vs Square for Cross-Border Sales
Which gateway fits U.S./Canada/Europe expansion? Below is a merchant-first comparison—geographies, payout behavior, dispute tools, lock-in, and practical use-case picks. (Numbers vary by region—treat this as a buying guide rather than a rate sheet.)
Quick snapshot
Stripe
Best for Custom stacks, multi-store, subscriptions, or heavy API needs.
Broad geo coverage, flexible routing, excellent developer tools.
Shopify Payments
Best for Native Shopify brands that want fewer moving parts.
Tightest admin/capture/refund integration; simplest ops—Shopify only.
Airwallex
Best for Multi-currency collection & payouts, FX control, global wallets.
Strong cross-border tooling and virtual accounts; growing checkout options.
Square
Best for Retail + online hybrids needing POS + gateway in one.
Great in-person hardware; online is solid, but geo scope is narrower.
Heads-up: Exact fees and supported countries change. Always confirm rates/availability on the official pricing pages before you commit.
Feature comparison
| Feature | Stripe | Shopify Payments | Airwallex | Square |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Geo focus (online) | Broad U.S./CA/EU + many others | Where Shopify Payments is available (U.S./CA/EU markets supported) | Strong cross-border coverage; multi-currency collection | U.S./CA/EU in selected countries; strongest in in-person markets |
| Checkout options | Hosted checkout, Elements, Pay Links, invoices, 1-click wallets | Native Shopify checkout, Shop Pay, accelerated wallets | Hosted checkout, Pay by Link, global wallets; virtual accounts | Online checkout + POS; simple hosted forms |
| Payout cadence | Varies by country & risk; configurable after history | Varies by country; tightly integrated in Shopify admin | Flexible for multi-currency; strong treasury/FX tools | Typically fast for card-present; online follows standard cycles |
| Holds/reserves | Risk-based reserves possible (velocity/disputes) | Shopify risk model; reserves on spikes/new stores | Risk-based; visibility into FX/settlement flows | Risk-based; often stable for card-present volumes |
| Dispute tooling | Excellent evidence APIs, Radar rules | Integrated in Orders; Shop Pay protections | Merchant portal + rules; good reconciliation | Solid dashboard; simpler evidence flows |
| Platform lock-in | Low—works across platforms & custom apps | High—Shopify store required | Low/medium—broad integrations, own stack | Medium—best value with Square POS |
| Who loves it | API-driven teams, multi-brand groups, subscriptions | Pure Shopify brands seeking “one admin” simplicity | Cross-border sellers optimizing FX & treasury | Retailers blending POS + web, pop-ups, events |
Use-case recommendations
Pick Stripe if…
- You run multiple storefronts/brands or a custom stack.
- You need subscriptions, invoices, or heavy API automations.
- You want flexible routing and alternative payment methods per country.
Pick Shopify Payments if…
- You are 100% on Shopify and want the leanest operations.
- Shop Pay and native order management matter more than custom flows.
- You value fewer integrations over maximum flexibility.
Pick Airwallex if…
- FX costs and multi-currency receiving accounts are a priority.
- You sell in U.S./CA/EU and want local-like collection.
- You plan treasury/payouts to suppliers or creators globally.
Pick Square if…
- You do serious in-person retail or events and also sell online.
- You want great POS hardware and simple unified reporting.
- Your geos match Square’s strongest regions.
Holds, reserves, and payouts
All providers can hold funds when signals spike (new accounts, rapid velocity, thin tracking). Keep disputes under 0.6%, ship on time, and reconcile descriptors with your storefront/legal entity.
- Good signal: tracking uploaded within 24h, clear refund window, consistent descriptor.
- Caution: sudden ad spikes, high AOV in new markets, missing supplier proof.
Dispute tooling (what helps in practice)
Evidence that wins
- Delivery confirmation (signature for high-value orders)
- Listing screenshots/specs at time of purchase
- Clear refund policy & customer comms timeline
Platform notes
- Stripe: strong APIs & templates; automate evidence.
- Shopify Payments: baked into Orders; easy team workflow.
- Airwallex: good cross-currency reconciliation.
- Square: straightforward dashboard; shines with POS data.
Platform lock-in & stack fit
Future you will thank present you for avoiding unnecessary lock-in. If you’re deeply invested in Shopify and don’t need custom flows, Shopify Payments reduces moving parts. If you expect to add marketplaces, B2B portals, or mobile apps, Stripe/Airwallex usually scale better across stacks. Square is unbeatable for POS-first brands.
Decision checklist
Must answer
- Primary markets (U.S./CA/EU) and currencies to settle?
- How “custom” is the stack: pure Shopify vs. headless/multi-brand?
- Payout cadence needs and FX exposure?
- Dispute history and evidence readiness?
Our quick picks
- Pure Shopify DTC → Shopify Payments
- Headless/multi-brand/subscriptions → Stripe
- Heavy cross-border & treasury/FX → Airwallex
- Retail POS + online → Square
Need a neutral agreement review?
We match and operate on warmed payment lanes under dual KYC and signed agreements— we don’t sell or rent accounts. Our job is clean approvals, stable payouts, and disciplined scaling.
Talk to a specialist or WhatsApp us at +1 (807) 804-0208
Cooperation / Advertising: marketing@irent.agency
Opening hours: Mon–Fri, 09:00–17:00 (GMT+1)